There's an attitude which says "There's a universe of strange stuff out there."...and after a pause adds "It's terrifying!". That's horror.
There's also an attitude which presupposes the same universe but adds, "Wow, let's explore!". That's science fiction.
And somewhere in between there's an attitude which adds "We must civilise it!". That's...bad science fiction. AKA, most science fiction.
It's commonplace that horror and scifi (and fantasy and porn) blend into each other at the edges, but what I'm suggesting here is a sliding scale, something like this:
Cowering in terror | Lovecraft |
Resigned to horror | Poe |
Defensive war | Battlestar Gallactica Star Trek DS9 Alien Star Wars |
Kill all bugs | Starship Troopers Predator Invasion of the Bodysnatchers |
Civilising the natives | Star Trek TOS Enterprise Planet of the Apes |
Enlightened empire | EE Doc Smith Orson Scott Card Babylon 5 Star Trek TNG |
Cute childlike aliens | Space Precinct Mork & Mindy |
Peaceful coexistence | 2001 |
And now, the next time you've got three and a half hours to spare, see if you can figure out where Bram Stoker's Dracula fits on the scale.
No comments:
Post a Comment